Unsung Heroism
In a sense, the Torah scholar is faced with a more difficult challenge than the soldier. Soldiers are lionized. They are given honorable mentions in the newspaper, awarded with marks of distinction, and their exploits and victories are publicly recounted and rhapsodized. They are national heroes.
But far away from the action of the battlefield, the Torah scholar sits and learns without fanfare. His efforts to protect the Jewish people (studying Torah all day is very difficult, as anyone who has done so, or attempted to do so, can testify) confer upon him no elevated status and glory; he goes unknown.
If anything, he is punished for his choice, subjected to constant insults and condemnation by his less religious brethren, who scream at him in self-righteous indignation: “Will your brothers go to war while you sit here?” And not only doesn’t his vital contribution earn him an honorable mention in the media, but the media regularly spews vitriol against the full-time Torah scholar and incites the populace to despise him, branding him a leech and a drain upon society, one who selfishly refuses to “share the burden.”
28 comments
If I was an Israeli then I'd hold them in contempt as well. They're exempt from military service and contribute nothing to society whilst getting paid for it. They're nothing but parasites. Cowardly ones at that. Israel needs every able bodied person to do military service, but these moochers get away with it. They could always do their military service, and then live off the taxpayers afterwards. It least then they would have done something useful for their country.
What benefit is it to society to sit and study ancient, and obsolete, myths?
Oh well, it's at least less harmful to society than the Israeli "Defense" Forces' occupation of Palestine...
There's another profession that makes this sort of comparison, so often that the British satirical magazine Private Eye used to (maybe still does?) run a column of such pronouncements. Members of the profession get very upset by its title, that might just suit Mr Oliver: luvvies.
I kind of agree with him. He's not a fundie, he's just hoping that his religion's main scholars receive more appreciation. Cardinals are appreciated. These guys aren't. He's exaggerating quite a bit, but I agree with his main point. If bishops and popes and cardinals are heroes, then these guys are too.
When I lived in Israel, everyone I ever met hated the way they had to do military service but Yeshivim didn't.
Not strictly relevant but there were lots of astonishingly lovely female soldiers, ranging from Finnish Albino to Darker Than A Pint Of Guinness.
Wow, first movie stars, now religious leaders claim that their jobs are just as difficult and dangerous as soldiers.
Now, I'm not naive enough to say that all soldiers are combat soldiers, but they're job is to literally to kill or be killed by an enemy in the interest of their respective states.
Worst thing I can see a Torah scholar going through in Israel is maybe some scathing political commentary. I'm sure their egos are in dire need of support Rabbi Oliver.
Sitting around and learning Torah is a ZERO contribution to the defense of Israel.
Close your books, get off your asses, and do your duty to defend your country.
If dozens, (Hundreds ?, Thousands ?), of people have to read a book, full time, for dozens/hundreds/thousands of years in order to discern the meaning of said book then I would suggest that said book is not worth the effort.
However, this sounds to me like the basic scam that the 'priesthood' has been pulling on society ever since the very first con man thought "How can I get people to support me without any effort on my part ?"
In a sense, the Harry Potter scholar is faced with a more difficult challenge than the soldier. Soldiers are lionized. They are given honorable mentions in the newspaper, awarded with marks of distinction, and their exploits and victories are publicly recounted and rhapsodized. They are national heroes.
But far away from the action of the battlefield, the Harry Potter scholar sits and learns without fanfare. His efforts to protect the wizards and the muggles (studying Harry Potter all day is very difficult, as anyone who has done so, or attempted to do so, can testify) confer upon him no elevated status and glory; he goes unknown.
If anything, he is punished for his choice, subjected to constant insults and condemnation by his less religious brethren, who scream at him in self-righteous indignation: “Will your brothers go to war while you sit here?” And not only doesn’t his vital contribution earn him an honorable mention in the media, but the media regularly spews vitriol against the full-time Harry Potter scholar and incites the populace to despise him, branding him a leech and a drain upon society, one who selfishly refuses to “share the burden.”
Yes, reading a musty old book of antiquated bullshit is just as valuable and dangerous as facing bullets, rockets, mortars, and whatever else in the defence of one's country. This is especially true in a country which has been at war for every day of its existence and a country which a great deal of people believe has no right to exist.
Yes siree, the two are very much on a par.
And they are taking a big chunk of Israel PDG because, unlike other rabbis or the soldiers themselves, who have a second job, because they just study the Torah, have lots of kids and expect monthly religiously(no pun intended)the pay from the state, contributing with NOTHING palpable in exchange. Even they make it even worse because tourists run from Israel when tourists are attacked for non conforming to their stupid rules. Something that you conveniently forgot to mention.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.