10 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
This book makes the point of a well deserved spanking, July 29, 1999
Reviewer: A reader
When I read this book last march my son was slipping horribly in school. My son is 17 years old and graduated with flying colors from his Junior year (a 98 on one of his Regents exams!). When he was little and acted up (through grade 6) down the pants came and over the knee he went. But I faulsly belived that after that he was beyond the "spanking age." When I read this book I learned that my son needed help and I had to give it to him. He had failed or came close too, most of his finals and was in bad shape (never listened, always late, smoking, drinking) and I couldn't bare to see him bomb like that. So, one night he came home 4 hours late, I learned that he had failed 2 tests and had been smoking again. I grounded him. He threw a fit and after a bit of a screeming match I pulled over a kitchen table chair, grabbed my sons wrist, yanked down his pants and spanked him. I spanked him for a half an hour. His bottom was as red as an apple. I kept him there over my knee and explained the rules. He agreed. Of course a few other spankings followed and may still follow, but he's doing much better with the spankings. And I have this book to thank.
59 comments
Unrelated question here, the contact fstdt link won't work and neither will the search function.
Does anybody remember a post from a few months back that got the "Fundie almost discovers the sun" award? I'm looking for it but can't find it. What month was it in? Fundie's name? Anything?
"10 of 34 people found the following review helpful:"...and probably sexually arousing.
You have BIG problems, A reader (no wonder you didn't use your real name).
He's discovered the Mafia technique: if you beat the hell out of someone, he'll probably agree to whatever you say. One day, the kid, humiliated and degraded long enough, will show up in this guy's bedroom with a shotgun. Either that or he'll grow up into a spineless wimp who spends the rest of his life working in a warehouse and being similarly abused by some redneck boss.
My dad spanked me once when I was 13 and it was traumatizing. It did nothing but make me hate him even more, completely lose respect for him.
If this is real-- which I doubt-- your son is just doing a better job of sneaking around.
Eric wrote: "Aw, MM beat me to it."
Yes, Eric, I beat you. Beat you hard.
:p
Oh, yes, MM, beat me, harder, harder!
I've been a bad boy :)
Did your spanking give him a boner? Cuz I was a walking hard-on at 17, and I prolly woulda popped my load. Both of my parents are really hot.
I'm kidding. Relax.
I still would've shot my load, but my parents aren't that hot. ;)
Yeah, I'm pretty sure by his age you've graduated child abuse and moved into sexual abuse territory. My dad's at least 6 inches taller than me, but I'm damn sure I'd kick his ass if he ever pantsed me and started spanking me at that age.
Your son is a wuss for not fighting back and you're, obviously, a delusional and evil person. I hope he alerted the police shortly after.
This person, and ten other people, need to be bludgeoned with softball bats. "We're just trying to make you better human beings! Physical abuse leads to ethics, remember?"
@Fanatic Templar
Look at what the lady is showing us, though. She has the boy completely and thoroughly emasculated. My step-dad inflicted mental and physical abuse on me since I was 10...It was only when I was 20, 21 that I finally started to stand up for myself. Never underestimate the power of a broken spirit to make a person to endure humiliation after humiliation.
How did you get a 17-year old kid who's obviously speeding on hormones and stress to stay still while you spanked him?
At that age, I would have kicked free and broken my father's jaw for the humiliation.
Luckily, he has been loving and compassionate throughout my childhood. Yes, I pity your son.
There are other reviews on Amazon just as utterly sickening as this one. Fortunately there also comments in response to the reviews, comments from normal people who consider "A reader" and his ilk to be sick, twisted child abusers
This is... unnerving.
Your son is nearly an adult, you TALK IT OUT with him. You don't spank him.
There are two situations in which one would spank a seventeen-year-old: 1. in some kind of roleplay, which is fine and you probably wouldn't be doing if you were is mother, or 2. if you're a messed up mofo like 'A reader'. If that is the case, you and your son need to be forceably taken to a good psychiatrist.
"My son is 17 years old .....one night he came home 4 hours late, I learned that he had failed 2 tests and had been smoking again. I grounded him. He threw a fit and after a bit of a screeming match I pulled over a kitchen table chair, grabbed my sons wrist, yanked down his pants and spanked him. I spanked him for a half an hour. His bottom was as red as an apple. ... Of course a few other spankings followed and may still follow, but he's doing much better with the spankings "
I think I saw a porno that went like this once.
It's funny. There is another post extracted from the webpage of one of the children who were raised by his methods. And the results were not good. You know, maybe he'll graduate, and use the money he may earn to spend it on the psychiatrist.
@ szena
"The guy doesn't realize that he spent the formative years of his son's life teaching him that the only reason to behave is to avoid punishment."
I'll bet it made all those lessons about Hell a lot easier to swallow.
Wow..... I've read a whole lot of sick and twisted fundie missives, but some of the reviews attached to this book top them all. Check out the one where the parents of two girls, aged 9 and 12, basically exposed their daughters and beat them in front of a house full of "guests." Just utterly perverse, twisted, and vomit inducing. Sickos like the ones writing favorable reviews for this book need to have their kids taken from them and be locked far away from the rest of society for a very, very long time.
Worst anecdotical evidence ever. It reminds me some commercials of a Spanish Brand of milk, Pascual, that tried to lure lower class people into buying their ridiculously expensive for the time product convincing them that their kids would be genius at school(there has been released, at the time, a study that correlated good nutricion with good grades). Needless to say, 20 years later, we´re still the dumbs of Europe.
What happens when one fail to spell "March", "falsely" or "bear"? Can we spank you for this grave offense, reader? Or was "bare" a Freudian slip, perchance...
So, your son was a typical teenager? Woe unto you!
You beat him for half an hour? How did you manage that without breaking bones? If you held him over your knee, didn't his "little friend" rub against your thighs?
Don't expect a top class retirement home after that treatment, reader...
In my country you'd be in jail for child abuse.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.