"I haven't seen any proof that the creationists are wrong."
This will often happen to people who ignore the evidence, and when confronted with it, cover their ears or read Bible scripture.
"Sorry your stupid catholic religion made you hate God so much."
Many religions are stupid, including yours. Especially the ones that enjoy ignoring science, or diluting scientific knowledge with batshit theological myths.
"That's ok, He'll open your eyes and ears to the truth soon enough. He controls your environment. You have no choice to believe or not until He allows it. He allowed satan to decieve you too, so you think you are an "atheist"."
If 'god' allowed 'satan' to make me 'think' that I'm an atheist, isn't this all your 'god's fault?
I told you He controls all of it. He made it, He owns it, He makes the rules and controls it. Get over it."
First you treat it as though it's 'god's whim that we're atheists, then you make it sound like we need to 'get over it' because it's our fault or something. Are you mildly fucked in the head?