Anonymous. #fundie storify.com

Scarlet Overkill's Ableist Portrayal in Minions.

I'm a huge fan of Scarlet Overkill, but like many characters she has her own set of problematic elements. It's important to discuss them.

I'm not referring to scenes where she's angry/has poor impulse control. She's a villain, & those can be a skill set.

Scenes where Scarlet appears like she has a dissociative d/o are played for laughs, but they make me uncomfortable.

One example is when she appears on TV. I couldn't find a pic, but her waist is unusually elongated and she's swaying. Why go there? I don't recall anything about the appearances/behavior of Gru, Vector, or El Macho that would imply a mental disorder. At least, one implying a dissociation from reality. So seeing Scarlet, the franchise's 1st female supervillain, appear as though she might be delusional/psychotic, dismays me to no end. It also makes me angry.

Not only is Scarlet Overkill's portrayal abelist at times, it's sexist as well because of her gender. She's a woman so ergo she has to appear mentally disabled? Really? That's the best the creative team could dream up? Why insult female audiences with an abelist portrayal of a female character, especially one who's otherwise powerful? Are they implying women can fantasize about power but should never actually have it?

Why send such a harmful message to people with disabilities? Implying Scarlet Overkill has a mental disorder undermines all her scenes where she's powerful, confident, etc. So while Scarlet can be angry like Gru & other villains, the ultimate & harmful message sent is she's inferior.

Question: Why couldn't the creators have just kept playing her outrageous anger for laughs?

Answer: Entrenched sexism and ableism are difficult to shake.

I took my daughter to see Minions. You can bet I warned her about Scarlet's mentalist portrayal and how it's not appropriate. Or funny.

29 comments

Confused?

So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!

To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register. Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.