Olaf D - "The Men in the Arena" #conspiracy #racist #wingnut #dunning-kruger

Olaf D - "The Men in the Arena" #conspiracy #racist #wingnut #dunning-kruger quora.com

calling one historic tribe Germanic and the other not, is based on what ? Material culture or modern Germany's wishful thinking and nation building myths with supporting historiography.

DNA studies of historic samples blowing these myths apart.

For example suevi or svevi were not what those German pseudo historians would want you believe And people before them knew it very well that.

R1a presence predates R1b on territories from Rhine to Vistula collectively called Germania. Before Catholic crusade to conquer and convert fellow Christians and ostsiedlung.
But we are till present day trapped in this late XIX-th century nationalistic chauvinism designed to grant Germans a historic reign over their imagined lebensraum, by denying peoples (that turned out via genetic testing of today to be by en large the autochtons on the land contrary to German theory making Slavs appearing out of blue from somewhere else, presumably swamp) their history, and right to their homeland.

2 comments

I think only Pan-Slavic Pseudo-Historians try to ascribe Slavs of germania and balkans to autochtonous origin
Perfect! A total and utter collapse of any semblance of logic, and a brutal assassination of History, in other words: Since the suevi were somehow and in an imaginary way supposedly and possibly related to the slavs and since the r1a slavic master-race of asia who went to germania and Illyria were possibly and maybe according to who knows whose testimonials “Slavs”, therefore the ancient suevi and illyrians were OF COURSE “Slavs”!

Reductio ad absurdum in perfectio!

Since black is red and red is yellow, therefore purple is green! Whom are they trying to convince?!
in addition R1b R1a presence not predates R1b on territories from Rhine to Vistula There's not a single R1a in yamnaya and Afanasievo labeled samples. Even early corded ware was largely
Presumably ie r1b-l51 founded an IE CWC, but were then replaced by R1a. Presumably it is still likely that the new males with R1a ancestey had been altaic speakers but switched to IE when they joined CWC.They found that a majority of early Corded Ware males in Bohemia belonged to R1b-L151, while R1a lineages became predominant over time

R1a was Indo-Europeanized by Z2103 and L51, the R1a Kyrgyz and altai people just kept their original and native condition.
So Kyrgyz and altai people never became R1a;proto turkic always was R1a, just everybody else became IE.the language is a remain of other
people who originally spoke it.

R1a is not indoeuropean

it's Turkic/Altaic
why Kyrgyz, despite not being IE, have such high levels of R1a - it was not an IE lineage to begin with

Olaf D - "The Men in the Arena" #conspiracy #racist #wingnut #dunning-kruger quora.com

2 comments

Confused?