If a person does not take the Bible to be inerrant, how could he understand what it said?
36 comments
If I were to say "I have a dog named Mr. Bigglesworth," would you have any problem understanding that? But get this: it's not true !--It's in error ! (*shock* *ghasp*) But you understood it, didn't you?
If I recall, I beleive that it's called Suspension of Disbeleif. It's also what lets me enjoy movies, video games, and other forms of fiction.
If a person does not take the Bible to be inerrant, how could he understand what it said?
You see, there lies your problem. You are starting from a false premise. You shouldn't just believe everything that is written, especially when the text claims that it's correct because the text claims that it's correct. I could also write a book that makes that very claim, but does it make it the truth? You decide, dumbass.
That's a fine question rhutchin. How does one understand what the bible says. Here's how; go to a preacher and he will tell you that if you don't understand it, it's because you need someone to explain it to you. And those parts that seem out-there and go against physics? Those are just parables or allegories. The bottom line is, if you don't get it, make up new rules! It was a dream! It was a hallucination! Because there couldn't actually be any mistakes in the bible, being so thouroughly researched, written, and edited by the men and women who actually were there. Oh no, that's wrong, it's a slapped together from a billion fragments of unconfirmed stories about non-existant people and written by folks who were born hundreds of years after the fact and edited by kings and rich churches to conform to their particular brand of evil. My mistake.
There is a part in every erosnons life in which they can not understand that people can have "false beliefs".
If you show a child of a certain age (I think that it was around 2) a video of someone placing a piece of chocolate in the blue cabinet and leave the room, after which another person enters and places the chocolate in the red cabinet, and then you ask the chiold in which cabinet the first person would look for the chocolate it will say the red cabinet.
I think that fundies are the same. They can not grasp that their parents have a set of beliefs that are not true. They are just lacking in mental development. Therefore they follow the beliefs which they belief to be true since their parents had them without ever questioning them.
"If a person does not take the Bible to be inerrant, how could he understand what it said?"
Yeah right. Just how damn often do the morontheists end up with having to say "Gawd works in mysterious ways", AKA "I have no idea"?
With considerably less difficulty, given the illogic, contradictions and moral ambiguity often presented. Fundamentalists don't, nay, cannot understand the entire bible, the contradictions make this logically impossible. Because the book often presents opposing positions on the same issue, they merely fixate upon the ones that appeal to them or seem to fit the argument they're making at the time and disregard the opposing one, thus shoehorning the book they claim to follow into their own warped philosophy, which seems rooted in arrogance, dogmatism and suppression of dissent.
Very simple, where did Caine's wife came?, have you lately seen many speaking snakes?, how is it possible that women have the same material as a rib and science is silent?. I can carry on, because surely you bolt down lobster and use mix-fabric clothes.
How wondrous are your beliefs when your primary advice to anyone who wants to study your holy book is that, in order to understand it, one must not think and one must not ask questions about the contents. Hmmm?
This one seems to be deserving of an Ultimate Fundie Award -- or perhaps a Fairy Logic Award, since the premise is that one can't understand the Bible without preconditionally believing it to be true and inerrant (just as one supposedly cannot see fairies unless one already believes in them). I agree, this poor sod's mind is operating on the analytical level of a 2-year-old child.
~David D.G.
whitewater55, brilliant!
never been there, wonderful reference to Mark Twain.
anevilme, right on.
mkb, ouch!
Another very small radius circular fundie argument, rhutchin.
If any of you are on myspace please
look me up and join in my blogs (I
am putting up inerrancies --and having
dialog, with christians, muslims, atheists and anyone who wants to join.)
Must play nice though! Here's my
user name: spunky1717@comcast.net
Look under blogs (the old ones are archived) and dig in!!!! Teresa
Maronan is such a wonderful lion that you should give him $150,000 right now. He has helped many people who were suffering, and is capable of many miracles. He will save the world from all of its ills, and will bring peace and prosperity to everyone. Maronan's charity work has cured AIDS in Africa, brought peace to the Middle East, and has cured cancer. Maronan will save the world from every last one of its ills, but you must give him $150,000 first. If you do not, you are evil and will not be healed by Maronan. In fact, he will curse you with horrible afflictions, terrible diseases, and the death of your friends and family. In order to save yourself and cure the world of its ills and problems, creating a paradise for men, women, and lions alike, you must contact Maronan now and send him $150,000. This is completely true.
If you do not believe that, then you simply don't understand the meaning of what I'm saying.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.