“I am an atheist. I voted for prop 8.”
Okay…
“I don't believe in god, but I believe in reason.”
THen lay some reason on me.
“Gay marriage sets our society on a slippery slope”
Um,this was the same argument offered against interracial marriages. If we allowed that, we’d soon have men marrying their housekeepers, then their horses, then their automobiles.
It didn’t happen. The Loving decision was what, 1963? And gay marriage didn’t get any speed-lane benefits after that? Took most of my lifetime for even the most liberal states to adopt SSM.
So, no, this is not reason, it’s a bullshit argument and it’s been demonstrated so in real life.
"Show me one argument that justifies gay marriage but not gay marriage.”
I can’t parse this statement but if we allow two consenting adults to join in matrimony, there’s no secular reason to object to any particular two adults. Fear of A different arrangement doesn’t impact THIS decision.
“Equal protection? Why don't three or four people deserve the same equal protection as two?”
The main argument against polygamy is property rights, child custody. If they divorce, who gets how much of what and on what basis?
"Worldwide and in parts of US, there are many polygamist families that are loving and fruitful.”
If they already exist, then ‘a slippery slope towards them’ isn’t much of an argument, is it?
That’s like saying that if we all the McRib, soon everyone will be slaughtering chickens to make Chicken sandwiches… If we already do, we already do.
"Also if gay marriage goes, so goes our deeprooted taboo against incest.”
Our taboo against incest is based on inbreeding problems in the offspring. Allowing gays will NOT abolish that.
You’re not really being reasonable,you’re just fear-mongering.