I'm amazed how incoherent Denis Alexander's arguments were. And this is from a man who has written a book! Wayne Rossiter was a weak opponent, probably because he isn't sufficiently biblically based. Frankly a Biblical Creationist would have wiped the floor with Alexander, but then Justin's bigotry on the matter wouldn't have allowed such an opponent. The discussion never ventured from opinions, never addressing science, theology or what the Bible says.

On Adam and Eve, Denis' scenario was a joke, and Wayne spotted it immediately but never skewered him to the floor.

No, Wayne, the variation we see is not Evolution, since it is at heart a degenerative process. Evolution requires the generation of new information.

So the answer is, Creation or Evolution, yes you do have to choose.