["Existence is alive." Huh? What existence? We are aware and alive, certainly, but how are you claiming that the paper on my desk is aware and alive?]
The existence of everything. I am claiming that what took the form of a piece of paper is aware and alive. I cannot say the paper is aware-only what constitutes it. I can, however, state with all truthfulness the paper is alive. It is moving-living, albeit slowly, very slowly, and within a boundary-which creates the illusion of a piece of paper.
36 comments
I disbelieve! I disbelieve! Oh GAWD, I'm disbelieving!!!
You know, I have a whole box of papers on my desk, my recycle pile, with rejected letters and papers and things. If I'm not careful, they'll rise up against me and put me to the Death of One Thousand Cuts.
wait, wait--I saw this in The Matrix , right? "There is no spoon."
Wow, you guys are like sooooo deep.
Well, the paper is made of organic material that USED to be alive. But to say that EVERYTHING is alive because "what constitutes it" is alive basically is to contend that all atoms, individually, are alive -- and there is absolutely nothing about such an assertion that is true or even makes sane sense.
If I were you, I'd go try to tell the nearest hospital staff about your little "insight" here. I'm sure they'd be happy to find you a room somewhere.
~David D.G.
No, paper is not alive. Ever seen the five characteristics of life in a biology class? Life:
1. Is organized
2. Can take in nutrients and energy
3. Responds to stimuli
4. Can grow, reproduce, and develop, and
5. Has adaptations
Somehow paper doesn't fit the bill.
Bogart used to smoke cigarettes by letting them dangle, and not really inhaling, while he delivered his lines. The cigarette was thus "wasted" because it was lit and burning but he wasn't actually smoking.
There's a line in a song from the 60s or 70s that goes, "Don't bogart that joint, my friend / Pass it over" and is basically a "Duuuuude, you're wasting it!" complaint.
So the Bogartting Award is a pot reference. What else is new around here?
David D.G. : It is a term named after Humphrey Bogart because of the way he held a cigarette in his mouth. It started in the late sixties. To "bogart" a joint is to keep it to yourself without sharing it. There was actually a song titled Don't Bogart That Joint, My Friend . I can't remember who did it, though.
The existence of everything. I am claiming that what took the form of a piece of paper is aware and alive.
Claim all you want. You might as well say that you're the queen of France for all the good it will do you.
I cannot say the paper is aware-only what constitutes it.
A statement that makes no sense.
I can, however, state with all truthfulness the paper is alive.
An assertion without evidence.
It is moving-living, albeit slowly, very slowly, and within a boundary-which creates the illusion of a piece of paper.
Another statement that makes no sense.
Thanks for playing but please, don't play again.
"And that, my friend, is why you have to use a bong, instead of rolling papers!"
Damn hippy stoners!
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.