Amos Moses #fundie disqus.com

(commenting on story "Wyoming Man Who Identifies as Woman Convicted of Raping Girl in Residential Restroom")

Amos Moses:
SIN is SIN ..... no one is immune .......... confusion about what is evil affects everyone ..... embracing of a FALSE sexuality not of the Creator God ..... is evil ....... and the embrace of evil ........... and is SIN ............

The Pantomime Princess Margaret:
Doing what this guy did (i.e. rape) is the sin. Being transgendered, if in fact he is, isn't a "sin".

Amos Moses:
wrong .... it is a sin .... it is a forgivable sin .... ACTUALLY both are forgivable sins ..... but they are both still SIN .............

The Pantomime Princess Margaret:
No, because being transgendered only means you believe you are not the same gender on the inside as you are on the outside. It's a huge stretch to call that a sin because it's not.

Amos Moses:
"you believe you are not the same "
and it is a false belief and a sin ...............

The Pantomime Princess Margaret:
They're talking about themselves...their OWN situations. How can it be false when you're talking about yourself? Are you trying to tell me that ALL transgendered people are in on a great big conspiracy together where they are ALL lying to the world?

Amos Moses:
"They're talking about themselves...their OWN situations."
so what ........ it is a denial of science ..... it is a denial of DNA ....... it is a denial of reality ..... people have no ability to change or determine reality ........ theirs or anyone elses ...... it is sinful desire .... it is sin .... our "feels" are not a determining factor of truth .........

The Pantomime Princess Margaret:
No, the only one denying science here is yourself. Your arbitrary definition of SIN is what's causing the problem here. You can only talk about your own reality, not someone else's. I don't know what it's like to be transgender either, but that doesn't mean I tell the people who are experiencing it that they are touchy-feely liars. I leave it to the experts in the scientific field. So should you.

Amos Moses:
nope .... i deny FALSE science ..... and saying we have any input into out gender is pure false science and fantasy and sin .........

15 comments

Confused?

So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!

To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register. Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.