If natural selection were true humans in the tropics would have silver, reflective skin to help them keep cool, but they don't. They have black skin, just the opposite of what the theory of natural selection would predict.
39 comments
And how many naturally metallic-silver, reflective creatures does this guy see running around in the world? Because I have to say that I've never seen one -- not even in National Geographic, and I think they've taken pictures of everything living. These people make me so, so sad.
So this is what "profoundly ignorant" looks like.
One could go on about why natural selection does not mean organisms can just evolve in any old way, regardless of the limitations of physics or biology, but this guy believes in magic and the supernatural, so I suppose it would just sound like "blah blah blah" to him. You know, kind of like when you talk to your dog and he hears "blah blah blah Rover blah blah blah food?"
It's peculiar that black have an enhanced resistance to skin cancer and the short, curly hair on the top of their head allows for a buffer of cool air on the skull as opposed to straight hair which has a nasty tendency to retain heat. Just as the Inuit (Eskimos to people who don't know any better) have extra capillaries and straight hair which seems better suited to trappping warm air. Please try again, Roman.
And I know you will!
The fun "silver skin" quote is secondary, originally coming from a linked page.
It's just full of this idoicy. (But I don't know if they should be submitted as new "darnedest things"...)
Take this, for an example, "The evolutionist ignores the problem surrounding the human female egg and the male sperm in the evolutionary theory. ... The female eggs all develop within the ovaries while she is a baby (fetus) within her mother's womb. Evolutionists claim environmental factors cause small changes in the offspring in the evolutionary chain. However, the environmental experience of the female cannot change the chromosomes within her eggs and cannot have any effect upon her offspring. Her body cannot go into the eggs contained within her ovaries at her birth to make an intelligent change. Females cannot be a part of the evolutionary theory for these reasons."
Here, he seems to be stuck in Lamarckian thinking.
Or this one, "There is no scientific evidence that a species can change the number of chromosomes within the DNA. The chromosome count within each species is fixed. This is the reason a male from one species cannot mate successfully with a female of another species."
Perhaps nobody told him how jumbo grapes are made. Or that human DNA points to a chromosome fusion in the past, connecting us to other primates...
birdseatbugs #8284
<< And how many naturally metallic-silver, reflective creatures does this guy see running around in the world? Because I have to say that I've never seen one -- not even in National Geographic, and I think they've taken pictures of everything living. These people make me so, so sad. >>
-------------------
In fairness, though I haven't seen a lot of such creatures *running* per se, I have seen many fish with a silvery sheen to them, and the glossy, light grayish color of some other creatures can approach a silvery appearance (e.g., some slugs, some snakes).
Oddly, though, I can't think of any such creatures that live in environments that require them to reflect a lot of light to avoid soaking up too much heat. Perhaps, since heat is actually infrared light (which is invisible to us), we just cannot readily recognize pigmentation that is particularly good at reflecting it.
~David D.G.
I'm thinking, you know, how the dark skin thing is not quite a perfect system and all... almost as if turned out that a chance mutation for higher melanin content in the skin cells was beneficial to survival... really, the fact that it's imperfect is more proof FOR evolution than against it. If there were perfect intelligent design, no doubt humans WOULD have wonderful magical reflective skin.
"So was god black, or white? I'm confussed."
Neither, I'm pretty sure he has this magic silver skin that Roman's insisting on.
Actually, that's what YOU predicted. People who live in climates near the equator who get more sun have darker skin not because of the light / heat conspiracy, but because of a compound called melotonin, which is a naturally-produced sunblock. Us Caucasians, evolving in naturally lower-UV areas, have less melotonin and paler skin.
Someday we'll all probably be really pale, because we spend all our time indoors, or tan because some people think that looks cool.
I think the idea of black people having silver skin under the black would be neat, kind of like a superhero thing.
Can I have gold underneath my pink peeled-lobster look?
um...ever heard of melanin? Also, there's a reason we sweat in hot weather. I'll let you look that one up. It'll do you good. Hint: keeping cool.
I was a lifeguard for 2 summers when having a tan was considered fine. I turned a seriously deep brown. The melanin just kept on rolling! Understand?
I'm older and have had 2 pre-cancerous lesions taken off. Use sunscreen.
.......oO
...OO
.....Oo
...oo
would you believe that people in the tropics are born white, but exposure to the bright sun turns them dark in a short time ?
did I mention that I have a bridge for sale cheap ?
“If natural selection were true humans in the tropics would have silver, reflective skin to help them keep cool,”
Okay, for Natural Selection to bring that about, that means someone had to be born with silver reflective skin. Do you have any evidence that someone was born with silver reflective skin and natural selection did NOT select them?
“but they don't. They have black skin, just the opposite of what the theory of natural selection would predict.”
Feel free to quote that part of the theory of natural selection. Where do you find this? How do you know this? What the fuck is wrong with you?
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.