Webster Hunt (Parts Man) #fundie

Webster Hunt (Parts Man) #fundie raycomfortfood.blogspot.com

@tripmaster monkey @ aceofclubs:

So, you agree that Christianity is good? And if you agree that Christianity is good, then you agree that Christ is good, right? And if you agree that Christ is good, then you agree that Christ is God - because no one is good but God - right? And if you agree that Christ is God, then you agree that there is a God, right? Sounds to me that in your attempt to insult Ray, you have disproven your own belief system.

48 comments

old comment by Sarah

(Christianity <-> Good) -> (Originator of Christianity <-> Good)?

Assuming Christianity is good: good things can come from bad things. If I'm a murderer who kills people for fun and I murder--say--a politician who would have committed murder on a much larger scale, without caring or even knowing about that consequence to my murder, the fact my evil deed had good results doesn't make me a good person. If Christianity is *not* good, then the logic is even more flawed. (To figure whether Christianity is "good", first define good.) Your chain of reasoning has failed on the first step.

(Christ <-> Good) ^ (God <-> Good) -> (Christ <-> God)?

Your logic in this step would be correct if you weren't using two different definitions of the word "good". There are different definitions of the word and you are equating "Perfectly good as only a divine entity can be" with "Ordinary workaday definition of good referring to a human who occasionally says 'please' and doesn't hurt small animals". If a given atheist thinks Christ was one of the above, it's the latter.

(Christ <-> God) -> (God Exists)

This logic would also be correct if you weren't wrong on the previous steps.

Intellectually bankrupt, boring, and smug. F+!

old comment by

(1)Christianity can be good, unfortunately Christian excess has lead to Holy wars, Crusades, inquisitions, and pogroms against other religions. So no Christianioty is not always good!(2) Christ was good, unfortunately too many members of his fanclub are self-righteous assholes(like your buddy Ray) who only lip service his ideals and damage his image.(3) No, people can be good, ice cream is good, cars are good, medicine is good, any of a million things that you enjoy or that behave properly or improve your health can be classified as good. Good is amanmade concept of enjoyment which is totally irrelevant as proof when discussing a God or Gods.(4) Sounds like to me that inspite of all your nonsensical sluffing, circular non-logic, and insults, you have proven nothing except that you think everyone is as stupid and gullible as you, and that Ray attracts stupid people like himself as followers.

old comment by Lithp

@tripmaster monkey @ aceofclubs:

@Webster Hunt

So, you agree that Christianity is good?

No.

And if you agree that Christianity is good, then you agree that Christ is good, right?

Perhaps Christ was good, I can't be sure, on account of the fact that I don't know the guy.

And if you agree that Christ is good, then you agree that Christ is God - because no one is good but God - right?

Wrong. God is the last thing I'd call "good."

And if you agree that Christ is God, then you agree that there is a God, right?

But I don't agree that Christ is God.

Sounds to me that in your attempt to insult Ray, you have disproven your own belief system.

I've never insulted Ray (he's a douchebag), but it seems like you've proven that you're a retard in an attempt to misrepresent my belief system. Kudos.

old comment by GigaGuess

So, you agree that Christianity is good?
Not really, no. Several Christians are, but Christianity has just become a reason to be smug and self-righteous.

And if you agree that Christianity is good, then you agree that Christ is good, right?
I agree that Christ, if he existed, and he did say and do the things that are attributed to him, is a good guy. You should take some notes from him some day.

And if you agree that Christ is good, then you agree that Christ is God - because no one is good but God - right?
Wrong. Actually, by your own Bible, your God is petty, spiteful, malicious and cruel. Hardly good.

And if you agree that Christ is God, then you agree that there is a God, right?
And that's a pretty big "IF" you're stuffing down my throat.

Sounds to me that in your attempt to insult Ray, you have disproven your own belief system.
No, in your effort to tell us what we REALLY believe, you've unloaded the motherload of non sequiturs.

"if you agree that Christianity is good, then you agree that Christ is good, right?”
That doesn’t follow. Christainity is a community of people. Christ is a specific character. He might be a con man, a magician, a lie, a fantasy, or a god. Christains may not be correct, even if they’re good.

“And if you agree that Christ is good, then you agree that Christ is God - because no one is good but God”
That’s another unsupported leap. You’d have to go back to the beginning and get them to agree to the biblical understanding of ‘good.’ They may be agreeing to a different definition.

“And if you agree that Christ is God,”
You’re way out on a limb, here, with unsupported leaps.

“then you agree that there is a God, right?”
This is all you, not them.

“Sounds to me that in your attempt to insult Ray, you have disproven your own belief system.”
No, still believe Ray is an conniving, manipulating liar, no matter how YOU twist my words and add to them.

Webster Hunt (Parts Man) #fundie raycomfortfood.blogspot.com

48 comments

Confused?