Psychiatry is unscientific: "mental illness" is a myth. The Bible never speaks of anyone being mentally ill, only that they have sin or seared consciences.
61 comments
The Internet, the plane, AIDS, gravity, and the Lunar landing are myths, too, then, hm? The Bible certainly never mentions that in the future someone will land on the Moon, or that Man will one day be able to communicate with people on the other side of the world with machines capable of making millions of calculations a second.
What do the fundies have against mental illness anyhow? Why this denial? That is what I can't for the life of me understand.
The Bible is a steaming pile of shit.
It offers nothing of any use from a scientific perspective. What it does contain relating to the natural world is mostly erroneous and of no value.
While I might be inclined to think psychiatry is more art than science, it has proven itself more useful than the superstitious nonsense contained in the Bible.
This is my first approved FSTDT submission, which I think is highly appropriate considering the fact that it's been quite a long time since I've been this disgusted with a pseudoscientist.
This BS that gets spewed by Smithers and his ilk makes me feel literally ill. I had been completely oblivious to the fact that such horrific ideas about mental illness even existed until I met someone who had been "treated" by one of these mental health "experts." This idiocy ruins lives like you wouldn't believe.
I've had depression for as long as I can remember, and had my first anxiety attack before I hit double-digits. What the crap kind of sin is a six-year-old capable of doing to deserve to go through that?? A little girl's conscience is unable to be "seared" without being pumped full of fear by people like Kent Smithers.
Sometime after my nineteenth birthday, I descended into an agoraphobic pit. It has now gotten so bad that I literally dread leaving my house and avoid human interaction like the plague. I start shaking if I hear people outside my apartment building and sometimes I cry if a stranger brushes by me. I had to leave college because of the depression and am currently incapable of working. DOES THAT SOUND LIKE A FREAKING CHOICE TO ANYONE???
These imbeciles need to be stopped. I'm on medication, and I'm doing my part to get my life back on track. And you know something, Kent Smithers? If it wasn't for modern psychiatry, I wouldn't be reading your painfully stupid internet drivel. I'd be dead.
[/soapbox]
The Bible also doesn't mention people with their heads shoved up their asses, but we see a lot of them here.
Just because the babble doesn't mention something doesn't mean it doesn't exist, and just because the babble does mention something doesn't mean it exists.
I can definately affirm the existence of mental illness, I have autism-spectrum disorder and anxiety issues.
Let me join the chorus here...I've got severe depression, Asperger's, anxiety disorder, you name it. All I can say is that it has not a damn thing to do with "sin" or "conscience" or "demons".
Bite my ass, Mr. Smithers.
I also started with problems at a very young age, biting my fingernails at two years old, passed around to homes like a jug of wine in a brown paper bag and losing my asshole father at four. And you're right; it was sin. I was blamed for it all.
The rest of my disorders came about as a member of the bible club. So as a child I was already evil and I continued to be evil forever. Yup, my faith in the lawd was awarded with more anxiety and mental anguish.
What has helped? Introspection, simplifing my life, getting rid of distractions and things that do me no good, and thinking for myself instead of believing lies becuase they were spouted from adults, or family members.
The bible speaks of mental illness, as well as physical illness, and in both cases it came back to; being evil since birth, not believing enough, or a demon.
So just because teh bible doesn't talk about exploding sewers doesn't negate the fact that you are spraying shit like someone just dropped a grenade in the toilet bowl.
This couldn't be because the primitive desert people that came up with the faith didn't have science, could it? Nah, of course not... I mean, the Bible mentions cars, computers, McDonald's and Wal-Mart, right?
...Right?
@anti-nonsense:
"The Bible also doesn't mention people with their heads shoved up their asses, but we see a lot of them here."
Imho, the epistles instruct the believers in exactly how to shove; and the priesthood, in keeping 'em shoved.
The Bible says nothing about Protestants and Baptists. You don't exist. Pas mal.
Oh, and the page is right about one thing: Freud, all things considered, was a stinking old dumbass.
The Bible doesn't mention potatoes either, so no chips, baked potatoes, crisps and come to think of it most of western cooking. So should potatoes be banned too?
The bible never speaks of the internet, you, Hitler, The United States of America, Albania, Hungary, the English language, or Asians.
Must mean none of those things and people exist either... huh, learn something new everyday don't you?
No, in the "good old days" of the bible mental illness was caused by "demons" and "devils" or "witchcraft" which usually resulted in the mentally ill being persecuted, tortured and killed.
I'm glad we live in enlightened times.
Fixed:
"The Bible is unscientific: "sin" is a myth. Psychiatry never speaks of sin, only that they have a mental illness."
-edit-
Damn, I hadn't noticed Mister Spak's comment...
so the bible written how many fucking years ago is right did they discover everything there is to know about mental illness's and prove them wrong and THEN right the bible i think not
smithers you should go back to loving mister burns
I suffered form major depression for years. I finally got it under control through counseling, diet, exercise and volunteer work. I also used medication as prescribed by my doctor when it was necessary. What I did NOT need was appeals to any deities.
I guess that makes a case for works righteousness then, right Smithers?
The Bible doesn't speak of cars, trains, or airplanes. So, start walking.
And get off the Internet. That's not in the fucking bible, either.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.