If someone believe modern man been here for 150,000 years then it would seem you have to believe that man was as dumb as an ox for atleast 140,000 of those years why then beg the question where did this super knowledge suddenly came from. Maybe a man was struck by lighting huh? Or maybe aliens are involved as in Stargate?
31 comments
Two simple reasons:
This dude seriously needs to read Richard Dawkins' book "The Selfish Gene" and get a basic grasp on memetic evolution. Yup, it took 150,000 years or so for apes to develop modern culture from, well, nothing. Memes don't just appear out of nowhere, someone has to think them up, and what you can think up is entirely dependent upon what you already know.
For a long time they were a superstitious lot, who believed in a mythical god, and whose religeous leaders forbade the study of science because it was "evil" and "of the devil". If they were caught in the act of "performing" science, their religeon demanded they be stoned, or burned. Sound kind of familiar? Thank Darwin that science moved on in spite of christianity.
Well, for tens of thousands of years, men didn't have time for much else except hunting and gathering food. And then it took them more time to really come up with the ideas we take for granted--like organized mathematics and writing.
Considering that they had to create them from nothing at all, I don't think I can call them stupid. Can you?
How about we drop Smidlee, stark naked, into the middle of a jungle somewhere and then we can see how far his 'super knowledge' gets him ?
For most of humanities existence our levels of intelligence have remained, pretty much, the same. We just know different stuff, that's all.
They invented language, tools, civilization, discovered fire and how to use it, and so on.
I'd like to see you try that from scratch.
Inventing language is a much larger step than inventing a machine for which all the components already exist.
Everything we have can be tracked back to a simpler form of that. Being American you probably think everything was invented in America after 1776, under the glory of your church but you're wrong.
Major leaps in our technology and agriculture came from our world wide trade and explorations before the founding of America and after. The printing press further spread this knowledge and when combined with libraries (a even older idea) can easily be seen as the father to the internet.
There is no mystery to the lineage of knowledges boom if you are slightly curious. Smidlee's crap up there is merely one of their stupid strawman arguments.
It took us 150 000 years to acquire this super knowledge, silly. It was slow, not sudden.
A man is struck by lightning every year, but that usually destroys knowledge.
“If someone believe modern man been here for 150,000 years then it would seem you have to believe that man was as dumb as an ox for atleast 140,000 of those years”
"why then beg the question where did this super knowledge suddenly came from.”
“Maybe a man was struck by lighting huh?”
“Or maybe aliens are involved as in Stargate?”
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.
