considering that Africa, Southwestern Europe, South America, and Central America appear to be split from one continent -- Pangea -- what are the odds that the continents split apart after the flood right about the time when God commanded people to disperse and fill the earth after Babel? That would explain how humans appeared on all continents at approximately the same time. hmmmmm.....
42 comments
Let's see. The choices are:
(1) God flooded the Earth, waited several generations for there to be enough people to split into large enough groups, then told people to migrate in various directions before he set the continents drifting apart. Then, people migrated.
(2) People just migrated.
Yeah, you're right. Option (2) is unsubstantiated nonsense. The Bible wins again.
Or the Flood never happend, the Earth is more then 6,000 years old, and people traveld from Eurasia to the Americas by glaciation formed during the last ice age.
Pangaea split up between 180 million years ago and 60 million years ago (from the first rift that started the Atlantic to the separation of North America and Eurasia). The genus Homo only began existing around 2.5 million years ago, and Homo sapiens only appeared around 200,000 years ago.
Sorry, supersport, but the great movement of the landmasses which the religious keep trying to fit into Peleg's divide happened far before humanity existed. As for migration:
image
Scientific consensus indicates that there was a massive amount of time between, say, the appearance of Homo sapiens in Europe and in North America.
@The Jamo
Why do you fundies always go for the most improbable, implausible and often downright ridiculous option? I really don't get it.
Because the more rational ones are boring?
"...what are the odds that the continents split apart after the flood right about the time when God commanded people to disperse and fill the earth after Babel? That would explain how humans appeared on all continents at approximately the same time."
Well, considering that the evidence shows that humans DIDN'T appear on all the continents at approximately the same time, and since the land masses drifted into quite distinctly separate continents many millions of years before human beings even existed (and since the Noachian Deluge story and the Tower of Babel story are mere fictitious myths), I would say that the chances are absolutely zero.
~David D.G.
Noah, wife, three sons, their wives, all from the Mid-East. OK so far. The question is if this is the family that repopulated the earth after the flood where did different races come from? Please answer next post as I've always been curious.
"That would explain how humans appeared on all continents at approximately the same time. hmmmmm....."
Given that they DIDN'T
Thats right supersport,
Humans first appeared in Africa,and then many thousants of years later appeared on other continents,
Do some research
Nekhbet
"Noah, wife, three sons, their wives, all from the Mid-East. OK so far. The question is if this is the family that repopulated the earth after the flood where did different races come from? Please answer next post as I've always been curious."
I've heard people claim that 'Ham was white, Shem was yellow & Japhet was black'.
Man, it's sad to see such a desperate attempt to reconcile reality with the bibble. Now that the fundies can't deny that Pangea existed, they must somehow shoehorn it into their mythology or admit that the bibble is wrong. And since the bibble forms the entire foundation of their egos...they'll get a really big shoehorn.
what are the odds that the continents split apart after the flood right about the time when God commanded people to disperse and fill the earth after Babel?
The odds are pretty low given that even if your story of god dispersing people is true, the continental shift would still take a few billion years which kind of negates your "young earth" hypothesis.
Napoleon the Clown and The Jamo : It's just because those with more rational thoughts know their opinions are not worthy of being spewed out all over the internet. Though there are quite a few voices of ignorance represented on this board, there are a lot of repeats. This kind of stupidity is generally in the small percentage of those that are ignorant and ignorant and have too much time on their hands.
Re: races
My favorite story is an anthropologist was collecting "death" stories (ie. how did death come into the world), and he was in central Africa when a Catholic priest offered to tell him the story of Cain. The anthro. knew the story (of course), but when the priest told it, using all the storytelling traditions of his people, Abel was the bad guy for interfering with Cain's herding! The priest had told the story in such a way as to be familiar to his people's traditions.
The anthro was delighted, and asked him "What does the bible say about white people?" The priest looked at him and replied:
"Sir, I have studied the bible very thoroughly; there is no mention of white people anywhere in it."
While an admirable attempt to reconcile the Bible with science, your theory is not supported by science.
Thanks for trying, though.
What are the odds? Completely null and void, that's what they are.
Pangaea split about a hundred million years ago, and there have never been a world wide flood, not while there have been humans here at least.
Oh, and all of today's continents were once part of Pangaea, not just the parts you mention, stupid. Pangaea means "the whole world", ya know.
Humanoids are only a few million years old, and did NOT appear on all continents at the same time. They started out somewhere in modern day Africa and walked their way out into the rest of the world over hundreds of thousands of years.
That would explain how humans appeared on all continents at approximately the same time.
Lets see... appearance of Homo Sapiens on continents / regions:
Africa: 200.000 years ago
Middle East: 100.000 years ago
East Asia: 70.000 years ago
Australia: 50.000 years ago
Europe: 40.000 years ago
Polynesia: 30.000 years ago
Russia/Siberia: 25.000 years ago
North America: 15.000 years ago
South America: 10.000 years ago
Canadian arctic archipelago: 4.500 years ago
New Zealand: 800 years ago
Antarctica: 100 years ago
"supersport", you have an interesting definition of "approximately the same time".
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.