Trying to say that humans evolved from apes is like saying the Empire State Building just grew out of the ground. Evolution is a crack-up that Darwin just made up to get attention
39 comments
And the fact that Mr Darwin already had all the attention that any promising clergy student could want???
Plus the fact that he was deeply reluctant to publish his "crack up"??
Plus the fact that all the predictions he made in his "crack up", have been born out by independent researchers???
These facts mean what???
"Trying to say that humans evolved from apes is like saying the Empire State Building just grew out of the ground."
The ToE simple claims that humans and apes evolved from common ancestors.
"Evolution is a crack-up that Darwin just made up to get attention"
Christianity is based on crap that Jesus just made up to get attention. Does that work for you, piano?
No. Saying humans evolved from apes is wrong, but close, since they both evolved from a common ancestor. Saying a building just grew out of the ground is crazy talk. So these statements have nothing in common.
...but the Empire State Building _did_ just grow out of the ground.
Yeah, there were all these trucks and civil engineers and concrete, steel, and glass involved, but once there was no building, and then there was one. The building grew.
Evolution is like the civil engineers and the construction workers - it's a way of lending structure to the process of change. _Denying_ evolution is more in line with the Empire State Building "magically appearing".
--GF
I can just see the scene out there at the Galapagos Islands:
"Nobody pays attention to me!(thinks hard) Wait, if I make up a theory about how we all came from a common ancestor, then people will surely notice me! But that's not nearly as exciting as if I said that God poofed everything here. Damn, I'm sure someone will see through my desperate attention-seeking episode; and they most likely will be a Christian Fundamentalist!"
Darwin didn't come up with the theory of evolution, dumbass. Lamarck did, decades earlier.
Pardon me sir, your ignorance is showing.
Darwin didn't INVENT the idea of evolution, the existence of which is an acknowledged fact. He helped to EXPLAIN it by his theory of natural selection.
And I agree with others that this Empire State Building analogy much more closely parallels the Biblical creation myth than it does evolutionary theory.
~David D.G.
As has already been pointed out, the Empire State Building lacks the key elements that make evolution possible: the ability to have its "blueprints" modified, and the ability to pass those modifications on to offspring. The analogy therefore fails - miserably, I might add.
Since only fundies make the claim that humans evolved from apes, I don't quite get the part about /DARWIN/ wanting the attention. Nor did he invent the idea of Evolution anyway.
Overall, I give piano15723 a 7/10 for making three outrageous claims at once.
No, it's like saying we tried and tried repeatedly over history until we had a design that could successfully support such a large structure as the Empire State Building. OH S***, THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE DID!
Ape is very general term in the context of biology. Ape would include gorillas, people, chimpanzees, spider monkeys, etc.
“Evolution is a crack-up that Darwin just made up to get attention”
I’ve made more than a few wise cracks that turned out to be true. No one was more surprised than me.
On the other hand, it would take some AMAZING effort to make a wise crack that stood up to scrutiny through two centuries, with new evidence added all the fucking time.
So either Darwin was right, or he was more prescient than Nostradamus…
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.