Why do the Jews see Hitler as the greater monster when the Nazi regime did what it did in time of war, while America's murders exceed the Nazi in numbers and heinousness in time of peace?
All of the murdered persons in their embryonic and fetus stages are far more innocent than any one of the adult Jews who were put to death by Hitler. In fact, many of those Jews were high criminals. Why do the Jews not vent any anger towards and seek the punishment or death of legislators, leaders, the people who are members of abortion special interest groups and etc. who have been instrumental in having abortion legalized? Why do they not seek the punishment of abortion doctors and other who have and are participating in a Holocaust more heinous than that which took place by the hands of the Germans?[...]
If the Jews are God's favorite people, why are the vast majority of Jews in hell who have died? If they are god's favorite people and ninety-nine percent of all who have died are in hell, doesn't that indicate that satan was the god that favored them?
48 comments
Because those Jews were people, people who had every right to life. Just as the Gypsies and mentally ill and all the others murdered by the Nazi regime were also people who had a right to life. Those slaughtered in North Korean concentration camps closer to our time? Also people. Hmong butchered because they also belonged to the wrong ethnic group? Again, people.
PeoplePeoplePeoplePeoplePeoplePeople.
If the Jews are God's favorite people, why are the vast majority of Jews in hell who have died? If they are god's favorite people and ninety-nine percent of all who have died are in hell, doesn't that indicate that satan was the god that favored them?
You've actually been to hell?
How is hell these days?
Before you spill more nonsense, are you sure they are in Hell?, what is Anna Frank guilty of?, why don´t they pursue legislators and so on?, well, in 1939 it was illegal.
Since when is Satan a god? I thought Satan was a fallen angel? If Satan is a god, that means that God is not THE ONLY GOD, and doesn't that contradict the basic foundation of Christianity?
Oh, and I hate you for being an evil bigot.
"All of the murdered persons in their embryonic and fetus stages are far more innocent than any one of the adult Jews who were put to death by Hitler."
After that comment, I couldn't respond with an intelligent argument, so fuck off and die. Dying is the only way to protect society from you.
image
I refuse to believe that even the most brain-dead fundie is unable to see the difference between a (voluntary) medical procedure available to all and organized murder targeting a precise ethnical/religious group. The whole post reeks of antisemitism and hypocrisy...
when the Nazi regime did what it did in time of war
What does this have to do with anything? No matter how much you want to believe it, Germany wasn't an innocent victim defending itself against a Jewish attack, the Nazi were the one who started expansion/aggression wars against the neighbouring countries. That aside, you're also factually wrong: some Jews were German citizens, and as for the others it was only after their country had capitulated that the persecution of/hunt for the local Jews started...
while America's murders exceed the Nazi in numbers
Oh? You may want to define precisely what you mean by "murders", and to give some hard numbers... Regardless of the veracity of your claim, this is a primary school level argument: just because the class dunce flunked an exam even more horribly than you doesn't change the fact that you failed. You don't see murderers getting acquitted because Manson had more victims than them, do you? Anyway, while there are several groups who have a very legitimate beef with Murikka (American Indians, Blacks,...), Jews are not one of them.
and heinousness
So, in your book, the elimination of a non-sentient clump of cells is more heinous than starving, raping, torturing and murdering cognisant humans, including real children? Do you also find removing a wart worse than murdering someone?
All of the murdered persons in their embryonic and fetus stages are far more innocent than any one of the adult Jews who were put to death by Hitler.
Technically correct, I suppose, if you equate "mindless" and "innocent"...
In fact, many of those Jews were high criminals.
Go fuck yourself with two meters of red-hot rebar, please.
Why do the Jews not vent any anger towards and seek the punishment or death of legislators, leaders, the people who are members of abortion special interest groups and etc. who have been instrumental in having abortion legalized? Why do they not seek the punishment of abortion doctors and other who have and are participating in a Holocaust more heinous than that which took place by the hands of the Germans?[...]
Uh, because unlike the genocide perpetrated by the Nazis abortion is a choice and it doesn't specifically target them, perhaps? Nah, that's crazy talk... [/sarcasm]
I'm pretty sure that Jews have their pro-birthers, but they don't seem to feel the need to relate their position to their religion. I know, this is a strange concept for a fundie like you...
If the Jews are God's favorite people, why are the vast majority of Jews in hell who have died? If they are god's favorite people and ninety-nine percent of all who have died are in hell, doesn't that indicate that satan was the god that favored them?"
You were allowed into Hell to take this census? I thought you were too vile even for them....
The Watcher: If Robert T. Lee has been to Hell to count the Jews, why didn't he stay there?
Because even Hell has standards.
Justifying genocide?
Just how sick is this prick?
Exterminating a whole race is okay because it's in a time of war? WTF? The Jews who were MURDERED, not "put to death" or "executed" were thinking, breathing human beings, you sick fuck!
This guy needs to die.
I'm sure we havn't even come close to six million aborted fetuses yet.
I'm sure we have, actually. If current rates continue, 1 out of three women will have one before the age of 35. Abortion rates are roughly the same all around the world, and it's been happening for thousands of years.
I'm gonna try to get this link to work again: Here.
That basically explains how Hitler was anti-choice (for his "perfect race", anyway) and why this comparison is offensive to victims of the holocaust.
*sigh*
Is there going to be a time when these folk are actually interested in theology?
For starters, Bobbi-Lee (mind if I call you Bobbi-Lee? Thanks.) Jews do not believe in an afterlife. Secondly, if you're going to use the argument that those folks who are NOT favored by God get punished, then by your own logic only those fetuses that God disapproves of have been aborted. QED.
King of the Jews: "C'mon people! I just got the numbers back from the home office and you guys are really making us look bad. We ARE the chosen people, people, let's start ascending to heaven like one! Slomo, it says here that you raped piglets and killed and ate homeless people. This is exactly the kind of stuff I'm refering to here. We don't need this kind of press. Now, we're thinking of going with a new ad campaign. I know, hear me out. We're really looking for something snappy, something with some 'zazz. Here's what our people have put together so far, some of them are very rough, they are still in the preliminary stages, so, bear with us. The first one we have is, "Be Jewish; It's HOT!" Now I like where your head was at with this, I'm thinking Paris Hilton as the bride in a jewish wedding, her looking at the camera and saying, "That's hot." But 'Hot' makes me think 'food' and we don't want any 'oven' association. Pass. Here's another; "I Think That I Will Never Do, Anyone As Beautiful As A Jew." Too sexy. I know this isn't going to fly. Maybe we can run them on 'Fox'. "Be A Jew: We've Wandered The Desert For You." Good, I like that one, put it with, "Jewish: I'm Lovin' It" and "Just Jew It". Now does anybody else have any suggestions?"
Of course the Jews are in hell, so are the baptists, protestants, catholics, etc... everyone who watches South Park knows that only the "mormons" got it right!
If the Jews are God's favorite people, why are the vast majority of Jews in hell who have died? If they are god's favorite people and ninety-nine percent of all who have died are in hell, doesn't that indicate that satan was the god that favored them?
I, personally, think it indicates the fact that Robert T. Lee is a fuckwit.
I always cringe when people bring up abortion because I know I'll disagree with both sides...
First, Jews are not responsible for abortion in general, which appears to be what he's trying to say.
Second, you have to admit that the Jews and other persons killed by the Nazi regime had at least DONE THINGS while the fetuses generally don't, so you could argue that the victims of the Nazis had sinned more than the unborn kids. But that doesn't make killing them all right, particularily if you don't believe in sin in the first place.
Third, Ad Hitlerum. End.
@Sandman:
What he meant was that out of six million jews and five million other "undesirables", statistically at least some had to be murderers or rapists or whatever and that practically all of them committed some criminal or immoral action while they were alive. However accurate, he completely fails to apprehend what it is that makes ethnic cleansing so monstrous.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.