Top posts since
last month

www.boards.straightdope.com

Jeremy_s_Evil_Twin #sexist #psycho boards.straightdope.com

@Lizard

A real-life example of a Lolita-type relationship like what I alluded to above(where the child is a willing participant) is that of Mary Kay Letourneau, a 36-year-old schoolteacher from Tacoma.
She slept with a student of hers for the first time when he was 12, and had two of his children before he was 15.
My link is old, but in new testimony from the “victim” (whose identity is now public because he is 18 and party to a lawsuit seeking damages from his old school system) the guy admits he made a bet with a classmate over who could sleep with a teacher first. Obviously, not a victim in the normal sense.

Not to hijack this into a GD/Pit thread or anything but…they aren’t traumatized until the social workers get a hold of them, is that what you’re saying?

Interesting that you brought up the Letourneau case. I always saw that so-called crime as a bittersweet “forbidden romance”, and very Lolita-like. (After all, he sought HER out, when she was released from jail the first time!) Also interesting to see that her “victim” is now suing the school for “failing to protect him”, and I can’t help but wonder…has his therapist convinced him that he was truly abused, and he’s working to set things right, or has age corrupted him to the point where he’s seeking out the big bucks? (A la Michael Jackson’s alleged lover…)

Merkwurdigliebe #sexist boards.straightdope.com

To me, statutory rape is an age issue like drinking where different culture determine their own lines for the “too young to fuck” category.

Like Rune said, in some countries the age is much lower. They seem to get by just fine.
Who reported the crime?Her parents?If the sex was consentual, and her parents filed the suit, then I think that it is bullshit to jump on the guy. I don’t know the circumstances under which he had sex. If he had sex with a 15 year-old who still doesn’t regret it then I agree that he shouldn’t face such a stiff penalty. Sure there should be a penalty, but its such a subjective matter.

And lets all remember our reactions towards the young boy who had sex with his teacher. Our opinions towards these matters are totally skewed by gender roles. At least a lot of people are. There are a lot of laws on the books that are just an arbitrary line drawn by someone who isn’t affected by that line. Drinking age is 21 in America but it is 18 or 16 in Europe.

It also depends if said 15-year-old has had sex before with another minor. That would affect matters greatly in my opinion. If she chooses to have sex with someone of her own age, it shouldn’t matter if she chooses an older guy
...
I am not saying that it is acceptable, but I can imagine a situation where I think it isn’t worthy of 10 years in prison. Imagine a guy who had some kind of prior relatioship with her who found her at a party where she had a little to drink where they laterwent off to a private room where they had sex and people heard them having sex and a couple of people heard them or may have walked in on them (your 1+ witness right there). If the word got out that she had sex with this guy through gossip and got back to her parents who decided to file suit, then I would think that it is less than fair.

But then there is the obvious chance that it was a dude who saw a really hot 15 year-old who was at a party who was really drunk and convinced her to have sex with him. That’s what wedon’tknow.

Tuckerfan #pratt #psycho boards.straightdope.com

Fundy signgle-mindedness? I don’t thinks so. This is not an issue of personal “morality” which doesn’t harm anybody. As soon as a person starts adding victims to his behavior he loses my support. A man in his 20’s who publicly has sex with a drunk 15 year old girl is a fucking scumbag- no exceptions


Yes, I do think so. Fundies make their decision based on the Bible, because they believe that it’s the word of God. You’re basing your decision based on the laws of the society you grew up in, you’re not taking into account the fact that other societies both presently and in the past have different definitions of what is correct. Hell, even different states in the US have different definitions as to what constitutes statutory rpe, and yet you’re still willing to appoint yourself supreme arbitor of what’s right and wrong.

You’ve labeled the girl a “victim” without ever meeting her. Do you know that she was traumatized by the event? Do you know if she’s ever had consentual sex with someone her own age prior to this?

When I was in my early 20s, I was bnging girls who were 16 and 17 (along with the occassional 30 year old), every one of those girls had more sexual partners than I did, and I treated them better than their partners who were their peers. I didn’t simply sleep with them, I took them places, listened to them talk about their hopes and dreams and treated them with the same kind of respect a person should treat anyone they love. Does that make me a bad guy, simply because of a law, which is more likely to be enforced against a man, who crosses an arbitrary barrier than a woman who does the same? Perhaps it’s the law that’s wrong.

I’m not advocating adults sleeping with young children, but that’s beside the point.


JustAnotherGuy #sexist boards.straightdope.com

A good policy for all people is to get clear consent before having sex. A little disclaimer along the lines of “Are you okay if we take this all the way? You don’t have to if you don’t want to” can go a long way and keep you out of a lot of trouble.

In my experience, but I am a guy, if I were to ask those questions, seem that unsure of myself, I would probably still be a virgin.

Date rape, by my definition, and feel free to disagree, is two people, out on a ‘date’ or otherwise going together into one of their bedrooms (usually a bedroom) consentually. Now, if the girl says no, and he forces himself on her and it isn’t some pre-arranged freakiness, I would call that date rape, punishable as rape. If the woman let’s herself get too drunk to say no, but stays conscious through the event … even without said or intended consent, I don’t think she has any case whatsoever. If she passes out… I don’t know that this would qualify as ‘rape’ but certainly a sexual assault of some kind, and definately a bit of a psyche problem on the man’s side.

Second thoughts the morning after does not a rape make.

Now, IMHO, if a woman asks me up to her bedroom after a hot, been sucking face, and having a great time night, she should probably expect me to make a sexual advance on her. However, if she says, beyond a whispered ‘no, we shouldn’t be doing this’ during the progression of actions, or I am required to become physical, that is a no-no. Many women say no during the negotiations of sex to hold out that ‘pure’ image they want to portray. Women, at least in my day, were still trapped in the slut or virgin categorization. But I don’t think there is anything wrong with continuing to try to persuade after a ‘no’. If she really means ‘no’ you can interpret pretty easily.

I think there is a ‘No’ (you are doing it wrong, try again)
and a ‘NO!’ (I don’t want to have sex with you.)