[…]
But fiction isn't just any entertainment; its power and danger lie in the fact that it can draw a reader into a worldview. It embraces the soul and the imagination. It brings to life conjecture and imagination. It teaches. And appearing as Christian, it can fool many.
7 comments
“its power and danger lie in the fact that it can draw a reader into a worldview.”
It can expose you to another world view. And if you don’t have a lot of experience with alternate views, you might be overimpressed by the one presented, if the writer’s any good.
That’s why we didn’t let our kids read just a few books within a narrow bandwidth. We encouraged many genres, curiosity, experimentation, exploration. Soon they stop jabbering about the threat posed by the monsters in their first novel and begin to weigh each new worldview on its own merits.
“It embraces the soul and the imagination.”
Hopefully. God, the number of times i’ve closed the last chapter and asked the book, ‘What did you just DO to me?!?!’
“It brings to life conjecture and imagination. It teaches. And appearing as Christian, it can fool many.”
Except Christain fiction doesn’t conjecture. It doesn’t imagine.
It reinforces. Restates, maybe analogizes, illustrates, for the purpose of buttressing one’s faith.
The best stuff just reiterates themes you should already know and hold to your heart, while demonizing anything ‘Other.’ The worst stuff is just a sermon put into the mouths of a few different characters. About as subtle as a rhino.
Wait, so is the upshot of that that Christians shouldn’t read or watch any fiction, even fiction with Christian themes? I’m assuming (hoping?) that’s not what he’s saying, but it kinda sounds like that, lol.
Like "indoctrination in Harry Potter"? "Worldy music"? Mainstrean education is often attacked by fundamentalists as well, for helping to think and discover the world and some of reality. Fundamentalists complaining of censorship when their sermons are criticized, and pushing related conspiracy theories , but who at the same time want to shield their audience from anything that contradicts them. "Danger, Will Robinson, danger! A scenario that was not vetted by the imprimatur!"
It brings to life conjecture and imagination. It teaches
Well, thought-provoking is what one should expect from good fiction. And if Christians, centuries ago, didn’t had issues with being taught about classical mythology then why sould you?
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.