Matt Osborne #transphobia

Matt Osborne #transphobia thedistance.substack.com

Name A Human Right Dylan Mulvaney Lacks And I Will Give You A Million Dollars

Name a human right that Dylan Mulvaney did not already have before his “transition,” or loses by transition, and I will award you a million dollar prize.

Note that “allowed to cheat at sports,” “sterilize the kids,” “all the hormones and surgeries I demand,” “the prison of my choice,” and “million dollar endorsement deals” are not actual human rights.

Freedom from ridicule is not a human right. Flattery and silencing of negative attention are not a human right.

Suppression of contrary voices is not a human right. A field of eggshells around you at all times is not a human right.

Privilege over others is not a human right.

Dylan Mulvaney went from obscurity to success, with a White House invitation, in 222 days. African Americans needed almost that many years to be seen in the White House.

A white male mediocrity has been elevated to “influencer” success, which the Joe Biden White House has confused with a human rights cause.

Dylan Mulvaney has all the human rights of any American. He can use Instagram to build a gigantic audience of idiots, just like Alex Jones used YouTube, and play for as much attention as he wants. It’s a free country.

Stop pretending that he is a marginalized person, though. A person in a marginalized community doesn’t get this much media attention, or have this much political valence with elite classes.

Membership in the elite is not a human right. Things the elites value, such as plastic surgery, are not human rights.

Dylan Mulvaney had “facial feminization” surgery. He went into the surgery male and came out of it still male. Only now he resembles a male who has been beaten to a pulp. Stop pretending this isn’t just validated self-harm.

Dylan Mulvaney can have plastic surgery. He can have all the plastic surgery he wants. It’s a free country.

But do stop pretending he is oppressed in his surgical transformations.

Dylan is choosing this pain. He has chased it down and calls it “success.”

This is a status chase.

At the moment, elites value the totalizing potential of “transgender” and all its new language rules as a form of ideological exclusion.

[...]

10 comments

Name a human right that Dylan Mulvaney did not already have before his “transition,” or loses by transition, and I will award you a million dollar prize.

The right to redress when publicly slandered, for starters. Being treated as a living instance of identity fraud. Being presumed guilty of everything from sexual predation to nonsensical intrigues that do not have to be defined and this presumption of guilt with no existence of a crime is used as an excuse to bar individuals from places or activities they would otherwise not be questioned over and indeed if someone else were suddenly obstructed in the same way it would constitute criminal harassment.

Your own multiple paragraphs of wild accusations that aren't even tangentially related to her life or career is a pretty good example. Cheating at sports? She works in musical theater and is a recent TikTok celebrity, where do sports factor into things? What million dollar endorsement deal? Why are you speaking like she's on her way to prison and strongly suggesting plans to commit sexual assault?

Your mouth is writing cheques you can't cash. On multiple levels. I wouldn't want your filthy money even if you had it and if you did it would probably be Confederate dollars kept for generations hoping for a comeback.

Note that “allowed to cheat at sports” and “sterilize kids” and “million dollar endorsement deals” are not actual demands made by real-life trans people. It’s all in the head of Heteronormative Crusaders (https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HeteronormativeCrusader) who demand “allowed to Holocaust LGBTs”.

@Malingspann #151532

Yeah, but acknowledging that would mean paying attention to them like they were individual people and not a collective anthropomorphic cartoon representation of concepts twits like Matt find confusing and scary all smashed together in a mass he can pretend is hiding in his closet and exists only to be scary and confusing.

Oh right, and to make Matt feel less like a special individual by having any kind of attention whatsoever like the most deranged case of middle child syndrome you ever heard of.

The right to not be bothered by Bigots.

That'll be $1 million, Matty-boy.

There's an extremely good reason why James Randi's $1 million prize increased to the tune of another $500,000:

The interest accrued in all the time that nobody could prove their 'claims'.

His foundation still has that ca$h in bearer bonds: good at any major bank. I've proved you wrong: in more ways than one.

Are you good for that $1 million...?!

You forgot “not being publicly slandered by large-scale campaigns.”

Cheating, prison, and endorsement deals are only part of human rights in your very warped and bigoted mind, Matt.

anyway, any time someone says “do X and I’ll give you a million dollars” (or whatever amount of money), you can pretty much guarantee that no matter how sound your argument is, that money AIN’T coming.

Transpeople would have a much quieter life if you fuckers weren't so loud. YOU are responsible for the increased attention they get because you won't let them be. It's very simple.

@Anon-e-moose #151539

Unfortunately, I think he’ll say he negated your claim beforehand with noting that there’s no right not to be ridiculed. Although he’ll probably try to repulse your work regardless, knowing such ones.

Note that “allowed to cheat at sports,” “sterilize the kids,” “all the hormones and surgeries I demand,” “the prison of my choice,” and “million dollar endorsement deals” are not actual human rights.

Competing in the sports of the gender you identify with is not cheating. Nobody wants to sterilize trans kids; puberty blockers are not sterilization. The right to medical care and the right to go to a prison population of your own gender are in fact human rights. Nobody is demanding million dollar endorsement deals, but just because you dislike someone does not mean they do not deserve popularity.

Dylan Mulvaney went from obscurity to success, with a White House invitation, in 222 days. African Americans needed almost that many years to be seen in the White House.

It’s amazing how quickly things change thanks to the advent of the internet and social media, isn’t it? This is not racism, this is you trying to do a whattaboutism.

A white male mediocrity has been elevated to “influencer” success, which the Joe Biden White House has confused with a human rights cause.

I’ll say it again —just because you don’t like her, doesn’t mean she doesn’t deserve her success. I find the Kardashians tiring but somehow they’re still famous, because the world doesn’t revolve around me and my preferences. And the Biden administration is capitalizing off of her popularity, yes. Random people don’t get to meet the President nearly as often as celebrities do, for the sheer fact that the quickest way to gather attention and support for your cause is to attach a famous face.

Dylan Mulvaney has all the human rights of any American. He can use Instagram to build a gigantic audience of idiots, just like Alex Jones used YouTube, and play for as much attention as he wants. It’s a free country.

Yes she can. So stop being a douchewaffle about it. YOU DON’T HAVE TO APPROVE.

Stop pretending that he is a marginalized person, though. A person in a marginalized community doesn’t get this much media attention, or have this much political valence with elite classes.

What the fuck? OF COURSE THEY DO. Even assuming that this is all for show… what else is new? The ruling classes have always had their pet minorities who were somehow ‘exceptional’ members of their marginalized class, through either being entertainers, very rich, sexualized arm candy, etc. Being rich and famous makes it a lot easier to be considered ‘one of the good ones’. Doesn’t mean that the rest of your class is thought of warmly, or at all.