“At best, an evolutionary explanation would only account for why we have moral instincts.”
Okay.
Evolution is about gene pools, not individuals. As the gene pool with the better morality tends to profit,then however the morality is generated, that gene pool would tend to dominate from success, whether it’s by tribe, city, nation…
I dunno if morality is programmed into us, but we ARE social animals, so we’re pre-disposed to accept the morality of the culture we find ourselves in.
“But once we're aware of the fact that that's been programmed into us by a blind amoral process”
The process isn’t blind. Better traits lead directly to success. That’s not blind.
“, we'd realize that we've been duped by evolution into believing in right and wrong.”
Nope. Not duped. Even if, say, protecting children is an evolved moral trait, that’s still a trait we do have and show, and it ensures the survival of the race. It’s not a trick.
“Our moral instincts would be delusive.”
Would you rather believe a lawgiver who has no reason to obey his own laws imposed morals up on us which he can ignore at a whim? Thou shalt not kill, but God kills right and left,and directs his followers to kill right and left. THAT’S delusional morality.