A Christian theocracy would not torture and kill them.
Given how an awful lot of present-day pro-Christian theocrats advocate for murder of anyone too different from them, press X to doubt.
As far as I know, Leftists are allowed to enter Vatican City without danger of being burned or stoned.
There’s a huge difference between a tiny country which is basically 3 city blocks and a park campus, has no military, and is heavily reliant on tourist income, and a full-sized country which has just been taken over by a Christian equivalent of the Taliban.
Why are the Leftists devoted to defending an Islamic, that is, an Antichrist theocracy?
The majority, and probably the vast majority, of Muslims living outside of an Islamic theocracy *don’t* want to live in a theocracy of any kind and thus they’re no more of a threat than a typical Christian. As a Theocrat, you are not a typical Christian.
once we have eliminated all the human and natural reasons as being insufficient to explain this paradox,
You seem confident that there are no reasons which you are capable of understanding. You might be right…
what is the supernatural reason why the enemies of Christ from the modern West are allied with the enemies of Christ who follow the Seventh Century heresiarch Mahound??
…considering that you’re asking questions which inherently presume a rather different reality than the one we’re living in.
[Edit: fixed a major grammar error]