“You could create rules, then the contestants being free willed could breake the rules because it suited them, you as the games creator at this point could
A:disqualify all cheating contestants,”
You’re confusing the game creator and the game referee.
And if the players don’t like the game as you referee it, they can stop playing.
“ every thing here would be well within your rite as the creator because it is your game.”
No, see, it’s MY game. Say my family is playing Monopoly and the creator walks in and says, “Putting tax money on free parking isnot how i created the game!” I say, “Well, that’s how we play it, yo udon’t have the ‘rite’ to order me to do it differently.
I anticipate your metaphor is going to crash and burn.
“Atheism is different to this.
Atheism says there is no ultimate governing body over this game we call life,”
No, we say we have no reason to believe any of the suggested governing bodies exist.
“we are all playing our own "game" making up our own rules as we go along."
Well, within the bounds of what society allows.
“If this were the case we would have no right to critisize or dictate the rules to another, for their "game" is there own created by them selfs.”
No, we do have a society within which we must cooperate. it’s not all ‘make your own rules,’ else it would be chaos.
THIS would be more analogous to LEGO building sets. Do as you like an it harm none.
"If someone violates the rules of your game, that is they are living by their own rules, in the eyes of the atheist it cannot be immoral.”
That’s total bullshit. Atheism does not mean ‘amoral.’ But morality is not evidence of a deity, just of a social structure.
“Most atheists though cannot live like this, because they cannot live without at least some of there own rules being followed.”
Um, sort of. I mean, I don’t murder PARTLY because of the pressure of society not to do that, but also I don’t want to.
“and like wise society cannot exist if there werent rules handed down from a higher authority, namely God”
Completely self-serving lie. Morals exist, but are not proof of a moral-giver with supernatural powers.
“For it is only the creator who has the exclusive right to impose rules.”
Where did God impose the speed limit on the highway?
“It would be immoral for a man or a society to impose rules on a nother man unless they were handed down from the creator of this world.”
Speed limits. Prove taht they’re divinely sourced, please.
OOOH! Slavery is illegal. Where does God say a fucking thing about NOT slaving?